The headlines scream recovery. NFT sales are up! Doodles are mooning! Bitcoin to $103k?! Before you jump back into the digital deep end, let's pull back the curtain and examine what's really going on. It’s because, frankly, those shiny numbers are covering up a very worrisome trend.
Fewer Players, Bigger Wallets, Bigger Problems
Needless to say, it was good news all round as the general NFT market posted a 10.69% increase in sales volume, reaching $115 million. Yes, Ethereum is flexing its dominance, up 54.17% in sales. Look closer. Way closer. The scanner total of people actively buying and selling NFTs, meanwhile, continues to tank. It’s been a brutal market, with buyers down a jaw dropping 76.8% to just 126,075 and sellers down 74.42% to just 72,336. Let that sink in. The pie may be growing larger, but each year an ever-decreasing number of people are able to get a slice.
This is not an indication of a robust, healthy market. It's a sign of consolidation. It’s the digital extension of Wall Street. Only a handful of whales get to thrive in the ocean while everyone else is left scrambling to survive. While the gap widens, the rich are getting richer and the other 99% are getting left behind. Is this where we were told that decentralization would take us? I think not. It's a digital oligarchy in the making. We're seeing increased wealth concentration in the NFT space, and it's a ticking time bomb. What’s in store when these whales finally do choose to cash out? The whole ecosystem is vulnerable.
Doodles' Rally? Or Token-Driven Mania?
Doodles had the biggest growth explosion, soaring into the third slot with a 490.68% increase in sales. Transactions, buyers, and sellers all skyrocketed. The answer? The impending launch of their native token, DOOD.
Now, I’m not suggesting the Doodles community is the worst. Let’s face it, this rally does not have the makings of bottom-up growth. It’s hard to see it as anything but a pump driven by token speculation. It’s the digital equivalent of a dog barking at a squirrel. From incentivizing the NFT to promote environmental sustainability, the token seeks to add value beyond the NFT. The NFT’s value is tied to the token’s value too. It sets up an extremely manipulative and volatile closed-loop system. Remember Bitconnect? I’m not trying to rain on anybody’s parade, I’m just cautioning against anything that sounds too good to be true. The market rarely delivers on those promises.
True, CryptoPunks are the ones making big waves lately, it is important to remember they are now trading a fraction of their all-time high. This is no glorious comeback, but rather a long, halting ascent from the brink.
Wash Trading's Dirty Secret
Here's where things get really murky. This comes amidst a deeply disturbing 50.24% uptick in Ethereum’s wash trading, ballooning that figure to $4.9 million dollars. For those unfamiliar, wash trading involves buying and selling the same asset repeatedly to artificially inflate trading volume and price. It's market manipulation, plain and simple.
This isn't just a victimless crime. More than anything, it erodes trust in the entire NFT ecosystem. How can we have confidence in the sales figures that they do report when a large percentage of their volume is phony? How can we build great projects and make fiscally responsible investment decisions when the market is being manipulated by greedy bad actors?
Increased wash trading on Ethereum, the leading NFT blockchain, directly contradicts the narrative of a healthy market recovery. It’s just like a company publicly announcing their record profits while at the same time lying and inflating those numbers. It’s true, and it’s a lie, and we’re all being played.
This lack of transparency and regulatory oversight is an invitation to fraud and abuse. Where are the watchdogs? Where's the accountability? The crypto world likes to brag about how they’re free from government oversight. This hands-off approach is problematic because it lets bad actors operate without accountability. We need to have an investments-specific regulations based regime in place to protect investors and ensure a safe, competitive, clear, and transparent market.
The data doesn't lie. After some downturns, the NFT market is beginning to boom again. Yet, the deeper challenges of participation downturn, wealth disparity, and market rigging remain omnipresent. We don’t have the luxury of being misled by the buzz. We have to ask for more — more transparency, accountability and more equitable distribution of that wealth.
So the next time you see a positive article about growing NFT sales, dig a little deeper than just the top line news. Ask yourself: who is benefiting from this growth? Is it a case of a rising tide lifting all boats, or the yachts getting a free ride? Note—because honestly, right now it seems a whole lot more like the latter.
Looking to get one step ahead of the competition and find out what’s really going on behind the scenes in crypto? Sign up to our private crypto market report and newsletter delivery service. Don't be a sheep, be informed.
